November 1917

No entries recorded: November 1–5, 1917 (5 days)
Diary scan, November 6, 1917 (Tuesday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 6, 1917 (Tuesday)

Chillsome

Following the style of the late Mr. Pepys. –

“I spent the entire day in the V Corps Park. – Having censored and franked the mail of the company I lunched with Messrs. Sewell, Bridges and Sam Soothill of the Chinese Labour Corps, after which Mr. Soothill returned the compliment by lunching with me in the mess. – A great deal of interest was taken in the ceremony of "Tapping the Keg" at which Mr. Winter officiated with great skill. – Owing to the thoughtlessness of a sapper sub of the 48th Div. who came looking for material (ruddy optimist) I was forced to return to the yard without my accustomed after luncheon nap. Mr. Redelsperger, of the French Mission was our guest at dinner tonight, after which we indulged in the old pastime known as "draw" – I will draw a curtain.

– Intelligence to-day give us the news that CANADIAN CORPS HAS TAKEN ALL OBJECTIVES ON THE PASSCHENDAELE RIDGE."

-35

Historical Context

Following the Style of the Late Mr. Pepys

November 6, 1917

Robertson names his model outright, Samuel Pepys, the 17th-century diarist whose own 1660s diary survives as one of the richest firsthand records of Restoration London, including eyewitness accounts of the Great Plague and the Great Fire. Robertson runs the parody a full paragraph: the "Mr." honorific for everyone he mentions, the mock-formal register, the classic Pepys deflection ("I will draw a curtain") deployed here to skip over nothing more scandalous than a card game. Then, with no change in tone, the punchline: "CANADIAN CORPS HAS TAKEN ALL OBJECTIVES ON THE PASSCHENDAELE RIDGE", confirmation of the very battle he'd been anxiously reading about from a distance since October 9. Of all the ways he could have recorded getting that news, he chose to bury it, deadpan, at the end of a joke.

October 9, 1917 entry →October 28, 1917 entry →
Diary scan, November 7, 1917 (Wednesday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 7, 1917 (Wednesday)

Rain – Fair & cool.

Lunched with Redelsperger at the club. Read the riot act to one of Flux's men about contravention of censorship rules. Carless came down. – II Corps is moving on Fri. so he is coming to live with us.  – Intended to give my luck a rest to-night but was inveigled to play  – No more news from up north but looks like corps is coming back.

-4

No entry recorded: November 8, 1917
Diary scan, November 9, 1917 (Friday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 9, 1917 (Friday)

Rain etc.

Once more spent the entire day in the yard. – The O.C. has informed me of his intention to put all yard work under my control from tomorrow. – Indeed a heavy task for my young shoulders. – The Chinese labour is becoming very poor – they are being spoiled. – The addition of the men from Gouy to the yard strength should be of great value, but I fear me it will be the reverse, if anything. – They have been having too easy a time of it. Received a bunch of "Daily”s from Harry Grimsdale to-day. – Campus news about the same as ever but the outside news! – Lord, what a split up the old crowd has had and the crowd that have gone west. Tradition makers everyone of them. – They have set standards that should stir up the Freshmen for years to come. Once more, after dinner was I tempted to count the chips + once more I was unsuccessful. & now the gentle Cooper having heated water, I shall bathe. – The French papers have it to-day that Russia has quit cold.

Diary scan, November 10, 1917 (Saturday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 10, 1917 (Saturday)

Raw – cold.

Tryon brought the Gds. Divn. Supply Officer in to brekker. – They are in Reserve somewhere near here.

Diary scan, November 11, 1917 (Sunday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 11, 1917 (Sunday)

Fine – Frosty

Just to vary the monotony Tryon & I jumped on the 2.10 and went as far as MAROEIL. – We walked back via ETRUN and the ARRAS - ST. POL Road. – Called on a friend of T's who runs the tyre press and watched them knock a few off.

– Capt. Laurie & Salmond came in to tea and stayed to dinner after which Murray performed some more of his wonderful card tricks.  – C.C.H.Q. should be back in a week.

Diary scan, November 12, 1917 (Monday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 12, 1917 (Monday)

Fine & crisp.

Nothing much doing to-day. – Big Bill & Rolston were at Camblain. – Somehow got to thinking I'd like a trip home to-day. – Don't know why – just got to thinking about it. – Almost continual strafing going on up front. – Fairly heavy about dusk – Either there is some activity or the people in the line are a windy lot – Murray expected a friend to dinner. (Tobin - R.T.O. - Aubigny) but as he didn't turn up they are playing bridge.

Diary scan, November 13, 1917 (Tuesday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 13, 1917 (Tuesday)

Fine.

Allen & Stockbridge – Gds. Div. S.C. in to lunch. – I like Allen. – He's a pukka English gentleman I should think. Sewell also came up to lunch. The O.C. & Murray went back to Aubigny with A&S. – Brought back a load, oysters & fish. – Took a run over to Camblain this aft. – more for the walk than anything. Saw Gus & went over his various jobs. Copious strafing going on all the time up front. – Also copious rumours. – Heavy casualties list in "CANADA" to-day. – Talbot Papineau killed. – Makes you fed up with the whole business when fellows like that go, and you think how they will be missed when it's over. Tommy Irving died of wounds. – He was a good sport & a man worth knowing. – Wonder who will get his place. – Dunbar or Bogart probably.

-15

Historical Context

Talbot Papineau

November 13, 1917

The casualty Robertson reads about in the newspaper "CANADA" was a significant loss: Talbot Papineau, a Rhodes Scholar and Military Cross recipient who had become one of the war's most prominent bilingual voices, publicly arguing for the war effort and Canadian unity against his own cousin Henri Bourassa's anti-conscription nationalism. Many considered him destined for a major role in postwar public life. He was killed on October 30, the second phase of the same Passchendaele operation Robertson had just read about on October 28, cut down by a shell shortly after leaving the trenches. The same entry also records Tommy Irving's death from wounds: "a good sport & a man worth knowing," about as close as Robertson comes to a eulogy for anyone.

October 28, 1917 entry →
Diary scan, November 14, 1917 (Wednesday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 14, 1917 (Wednesday)

Fine.

Very little doing. – A few cars in. Some chaps in from 16 squadron looking for material. – Don + Ferguson. – Drove me over to Viller + I walked back. – No mail. Tobin, R.T.O. Aubigny came down to dinner. – We made Murray change his seat to advantage. Winter went on leave.

-2

Diary scan, November 15, 1917 (Thursday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 15, 1917 (Thursday)

Fine.

Winter being away I didn't wake up too early. Wandered in the yard and listened to Bridges ravings till I got fed up so went over to the club with Murray. – Saw the cas. list in the times. – Bill Morris & Jack Almon both gone west. – McCartney wounded. – Pat's have evidently been knocked about. Bob McCaulay also among the wounded. Tyron & I took another trip to MAROEIL this aft & walked back. – Called at the field cashier's. Salmond in to tea. – No mail.

+8

Where Things Stand

The Casualty Lists Keep Coming

November 15–18, 1917

A cluster of names arrives in pieces over four days, the way casualty news actually reached the rear: Bill Morris and Jack Almon both "gone west," McCartney and Bob McCaulay wounded, all read off the casualty list at the club on the 15th. The next day brings Cummings (wounded, a "Blitey" according to a friend's letter) and Bowles, reported dead of wounds, which Robertson hopes is a mistake. It isn't: confirmation comes on the 18th. It is the same slow accumulation as the five names recorded over nine days in April 1916.

The April 1916 death cluster →
Diary scan, November 16, 1917 (Friday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 16, 1917 (Friday)

Dull.

Allen & Stockridge in this morning. – Moving tomorrow. Bond. – #2 Forest Party also in.

Took Peake nag out for a bit of an exercise after lunch. – First time top side a horse in three months.

Capt. Laurie in to tea & dinner. – Also spent the evening & four francs. Cummings name in the Cas. list. – Letter from Pete says it is a Blitey. – Also said old Bowles died of wounds. I hope it is a mistake. Some of Murrays old crowd in this aft. –They are moving too. – Of course every outfit that moves these days is "bound for Italy". – The "Mail" puts the Bosche 15 miles from Venice so they had better hurry.

+39

Diary scan, November 17, 1917 (Saturday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 17, 1917 (Saturday)

Fine.

Got off some much delayed mail home.

Visited the club with Murray & Eddy at noon. Junkin came in to lunch. – Took Peake's nag out again this aft. – Went over to BRAY & saw a rugger match. Sewell came over to dinner.

Diary scan, November 18, 1917 (Sunday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 18, 1917 (Sunday)

Dull.

Young Whiting was in the yard this A.M. – Confirmed report of Bowles death. – Co'y at ABLAIN – Must get over to see them. 215th played 172 Tun. Co'y this aft. near La Targette. – Rode Peake's nag up & P. drove Eddy in the side-car.

172 have a fine mess entertained us to tea & dinner. – Massey Baker is with them but was up forward. – A merry evening as they sport a piano & two gramaphones.

– Beat Peake home.  The O.C. payed the Co'y their xmas money to-day & they celebrated.

Diary scan, November 19, 1917 (Monday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 19, 1917 (Monday)

✉ He also wrote to Doris this day

Dull.

Nothing much doing.

Tryon got orders to transfer to Noeux-les-Mines. – We're all damn fed up about that. Capt. Laurie came in to dinner & spent the evening. The chinks have about reached the limit as regards slacking. – They know they have a good thing and are playing it. – Sewell & bridges can do absolutely nothing.

Diary scan, November 20, 1917 (Tuesday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 20, 1917 (Tuesday)

Drizzly

Gus came in this morning with a yarn about several Divs. hopping the bags down Cambrai way, very successfully. Roston & Ormy Stitt blew in this aft. with a repetition of the yarn adding 400 tanks, – cavalry – and flocks of prisoners. Murray went out to dinner with his old crowd so the rest of us wrote letters this eve’g. Malcolm has come out as C.R.E. 4th.

Historical Context

Cambrai, Inflated in the Retelling

November 20, 1917

The rumor reaching Robertson secondhand, "several Divs. hopping the bags down Cambrai way", matched the real event: the Battle of Cambrai opened that same morning, the first battle in history built around massed tanks, with the largest tank force yet assembled crossing a roughly 10km front. By the afternoon, when the story reaches him again from Rolston and Ormy Stitt, it has grown, 400 tanks, cavalry, and "flocks of prisoners" added on top of the original report as it passed mouth to mouth behind the line. The "400 tanks" figure happens to land close to the count (476 fielded, 378 in combat roles).

Diary scan, November 21, 1917 (Wednesday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 21, 1917 (Wednesday)

Rain.

Tryon's successor arrived. – A very mild-mannered chap from up near Pop. Nothing much more about the 3rd Army show except that all goes well. – leave it to Byng for that. Big Bill payed the yard a visit to-day – Didn't see him. – Giving all my time to Conan Doyle and his history of the war. Eddy got away to-night after a heartbreaking farewell. Murray has brought up a pal. – Capt. Burt of the Civil Services Rifles to spend the night.

Diary scan, November 22, 1917 (Thursday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 22, 1917 (Thursday)

Nothing much doing.

Dunbar & Scotty were round this morning. Ed. Garrow drifted in this aft. from Auchel.

Diary scan, November 23, 1917 (Friday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 23, 1917 (Friday)

Fine.

Lots of Xmas mail going home.

Rode over to Ch. la Haie this aft. – Came back via Villers and looked round the old place. – Somehow or other Villers seems like an old home to me.  – Saw Wilkes & Hertzy at Div.  – We had to speak to Wheeler about the rations to-day. – I guess it was a mistake on Cooper's part that caused it. – Just the same W. is rather a frost after Eddy. – Peake suggested the old game of Pontoon as being suitable for four.

+9

Diary scan, November 24, 1917 (Saturday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 24, 1917 (Saturday)

Blustery.

F.W.Q.M.S. Grant shifted down from Gouy. Smeed Bull was down. Went for a short ride this aft but too windy to be decent. Sewell & Sam called for me and we breezed over to Acq. in a tender. Met a couple of their pals of the 19th Bn (Capt. Melanson & the M.O.) – The old lady made us omelettes so we stayed the evening. – Sam played & Mel sang. Called at the club on the way back it gets quite a lot of patronage. – Also called on Murray.

Diary scan, November 25, 1917 (Sunday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 25, 1917 (Sunday)

Wind & sleet.

Fine brisk morning. – Rushed the mail & took Venus out for a canter. Up round Mt. St. Eloi & back thru BRAY – Came up pretty stormy after lunch so the fire looked good to all of us. Spent the aft finishing of Conan Doyle's "History" – Laurie & Salmon came in to dinner so we initiated Salmon.

-6

Diary scan, November 26, 1917 (Monday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 26, 1917 (Monday)

Cold – Wind

Pretty near froze before Cooper got the fire lit this A.M. – Nothing much else to report. Went to MAROEIL with Murray & tramped back. No mail. – Held down a chair by the fire. Turning to rain to-night

Diary scan, November 27, 1917 (Tuesday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 27, 1917 (Tuesday)

Rain. – Blustery

Very little to report.

Wrote my Xmas letters home this aft. instead of going down to the yard. – Hard to write a letter full of Christmas spirit on a rainy day in Nov. Gus came down to tea & dinner. Murray's friend Burt blew in again with another chap in time for dinner & we are putting them up.

+19

Diary scan, November 28, 1917 (Wednesday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 28, 1917 (Wednesday)

Fine.

Nothing much doing. – Went out for a ride this aft. – Watching them stunting up at #8 Sqdn. – Monty came along. – Going on leave. – Brought him down & put him on the 3.20.

Got a deuce of a calling by mail this aft. – Only a card but quite suffish. – Hanged if I know how to answer it. – Seems like I might as well throw in my chips. – I hate to answer it the same for for it would arrive just about Xmas, & yet I can't take it & say nothing.

-25

Where Things Stand

"Might as Well Throw in My Chips"

November 28, 1917

A card arrives by mail (no sender named, no content quoted) and Robertson's reaction is hard to read: "quite suffish," "hanged if I know how to answer it," and then, starkest of all, "seems like I might as well throw in my chips." The shape of it echoes the Hazel thread traced elsewhere on this site: a card rather than a letter, distress over how to answer it, "throw in my chips" reading less like a bad day than like a man weighing whether to give up on something, much the same register as "One Measly Card" back on July 20. Her name doesn't appear here, though, and the year's remaining entries don't come back to it.

Diary scan, November 29, 1917 (Thursday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 29, 1917 (Thursday)

Fine.

No papers to-day.

Rode up to the dentists (C.C. Dental Clinic) at Quatre Vents this aft. No one came in & met no one. Wheeler introduced a new game into the mess. – Attaque. – Not half bad.

+8

Diary scan, November 30, 1917 (Friday)
Original page · click to enlarge

November 30, 1917 (Friday)

Rode out Berthonval way & in to Villers by the old overland route. – Called at Field Cashiers (II) being the last day of the month and Dec. liable to be an expensive one too.

Have just been figuring out probable expenses for the next couple of months to see if I could slip something into this war loan. I've missed them all up to date. – Don't suppose I'll get leave before I've paid it off, altho we are getting six a week this month. Capt. Watt (12th F.C.) came in with Laurie and stayed to dinner. – L. had his usual luck. – So did Murray. Watt says a lot of the 5th Div. people are coming out & exchanging with people out here. – Don't suppose it makes much diff to me

+35